How to Disagree Without Losing Respect


How to Disagree Without Losing Respect

At the farewell party my friends threw for me before I moved from Iowa to Florida, one of my good friends told someone else she thought I was making a mistake.

She never said it to me. I heard about it a few days before I left Iowa.

By then, I’d spent three months preparing for the move, and the few belongings I was taking were packed into the RV in my driveway. I had listened to my intuition, worked through the details, and chosen the life I wanted to create. My friend was free to think I was making a mistake. I was free to move anyway.

I didn’t need to make her wrong to be right for myself.

That feels more difficult for us to do now, not only in our personal relationships but in the way we speak to one another as a society. We argue to prove our position instead of listening to understand someone else’s. A difference of opinion quickly becomes a verdict about the other person’s intelligence, character, or heart.

What happened to agreeing to disagree?

Disagreement is not disrespect

Two people often look at the same situation, bring different experiences to it, and reach different conclusions. That does not automatically make one informed and the other ignorant. It makes them two people seeing life through different histories, values, fears, and hopes.

We lose the possibility of a real conversation when our first goal is to win. We listen for the flaw in the other person’s argument. We prepare our response before they finish speaking. We collect examples that support what we already believe and dismiss anything that asks us to see it from another perspective.

Understanding asks us to become curious.

Instead of “How do I prove this person wrong?” ask, “What led you to see it that way?”

That question does not surrender your beliefs. It opens a door between two human beings.

Understanding is not agreement

Somewhere along the way, many of us began treating understanding as endorsement. We worry that listening respectfully weakens our position or gives the other person permission to believe something we oppose.

Listening does neither.

It's possible to comprehend how someone reached a conclusion and still disagree with it. Respect the experiences that shaped a person without adopting their beliefs. Say, “I understand why you see it that way. I still see it differently.”

There are also moments when agreement to disagree is not the right response. Harm, cruelty, and violations of dignity deserve a clear stand. Respectful disagreement does not require silence, self-abandonment, or tolerating behavior that hurts you or someone else.

The work is learning to tell the difference between a disagreement that invites conversation and a violation that requires a boundary.

Self-trust makes room for difference

When you trust your own choice, another person’s differing opinion loses some of its power. You no longer need to explain the same decision five different ways, searching for the version that earns approval.

Before you defend yourself again, ask yourself what you want from the conversation. Do you want to be understood, or do you need validation through agreement? Are you exchanging perspectives, or fighting for permission you do not need?

Then allow that clarity to guide your response.

Explain your decision once when the relationship deserves an explanation. Listen when the other person speaks. Answer genuine questions. Then stop when the conversation becomes a contest.

“I hear your concern. This is still the right decision for me.”

That is what grounded self-trust sounds like.

We restore the art by practicing it

We will not return to a culture of respectful disagreement by waiting for everyone else to become calmer, kinder, or more reasonable. We return one conversation at a time, leading by example.

We ask a question before making an assumption. We look for the heart of the person underneath their position. We refuse to turn people into enemies simply because they reached a different conclusion. We hold our values without using them as weapons.

Agreeing to disagree is not weak. It requires enough confidence to let another person keep their opinion without allowing it to define you.

My friend thought my move to Florida was a mistake. I moved, and the Sunshine State became home. Her opinion did not prevent me from creating the life I wanted, and my decision did not need me to prove that she was wrong.

The next time a conversation starts turning into a battle, take a timeout. Ask one sincere question. Listen to the answer without preparing your rebuttal.

Stand by your values. Stay curious about theirs.

PO Box 19082, Panama City Beach, FL 32417
​Unsubscribe · Preferences​

Hello, Possibility Newsletter

For anyone who has ever thought, 'There has to be more than this.' Most people create their life by default. Every week I share one story and one tool to help you start creating yours on purpose.

Read more from Hello, Possibility Newsletter
Lisa smiles in aviator sunglasses and a yellow floral swimsuit, her hair blowing in the wind along Panama City Beach.

Give Yourself Some Credit Last week, I wrote about the things I learned to appreciate after I moved away from Iowa. Lilacs, a good pork tenderloin sandwich, and cold tap water. I stand by that last one. Distance changes what I notice about myself, too. When I look back on a hard period, I tend to remember how it started. Given a little more space, I see the person who had to get up every morning and figure out what to do next. She was doing the best she knew how with what she had. I am...

Purple lilacs with white-edged petals among green leaves, photographed in Iowa before my move to Florida.

The Things You Miss, the Gratitude You Find As I prepared my move from Iowa to Northwest Florida, there were things I knew I would miss, but I never imagined I would be placing myself in a fried pork tenderloin sandwich desert. I was excited about all the new things I would experience. There was a whole new ecosystem with different birds, alligators, black bears, trees and plants. And lots of foods I had never tried. It was interesting to me how we have such diverse food cultures within the...

Lisa's creation box with beach items

The Life You Once Wished For I was still living in Iowa when I made a Creation Box, an exercise from Abraham Hicks. It’s similar to a vision board, except you collect photos, words, and even small objects to place in a box representing things you’d love to have or experience in your life. Mine was mostly photos, and one of them showed someone sitting on a beach. Vacations were a rarity back then, so being in a position where I could spend time at the beach more often sounded wonderful. I had...